With everyone present we got going ASAP.
To be continued....
With everyone present we got going ASAP.
To be continued....
"Concentrating forces roll a d6 to determine their times of arrival. One is deducted from the roll if the attacker is concentrating in the defending area; one is deducted from the roll if the defender is concentrating in the attacking area; two is deducted from the roll if the concentrating force is pinned by an enemy force¹² that is not itself concentrating and is at least half the strength of the force it is pinning; one is deducted from the roll if the force has a green pin; one is deducted from the roll if the force would normally activate on a different card to the attacking or defending force (unless acting on a Joint Command card).⁴"
What a ding-dong of a battle this was going to be!
On Wednesday evening Peter and I got together to continue with the map moves for campaign turn 4. Only Peter and I were present, Mark and Graham having other commitments, but we had been given license at the previous meeting to act in their stead. As it was, only three campaign activation cards were turned before something significant happened.
So here, as promised, are the campaign rules as I currently have them. Plus, you'll find some cobbled together author's notes at the end to explain why some of the rules are as they are.
What I can't do here are the full Army OOB / list tables, or the cards that go to make up the Activation Deck (36 cards) and the Events Deck (61 cards). These are in MS Word tables format and they fall to bits when I cut and paste them to this blog.
However, anyone wanting all the files, including the rules, lists and all, can email me (email@example.com) and I'll send you everything I have except the map - that you will need to download for yourself (it's free here). Be warned - it might take me a few days to get round to replying, please bear with me.
A Peninsular War Campaign for four Payers ¹
Forces and Stacking
Forces: Each pin on the map represents one or more infantry divisions. Each pin is called a force. The minimum strength of a force is one division. Where a force is more than one division strong, only the pin of the army commander or leading division will be used to note the force’s location on the map; any accompanying divisions will be noted in the player’s army lists – thus an element of fog of war can be maintained before contact.
Command: A force not under the command of the army commander will be led by a force commander. The force commander must be a named corps commander where available, otherwise the force will be led by the most senior division commander – as an acting corps commander. When leading an independent force, corps commanders get 3 PMP, acting corps commanders get 2 PMP. Note: When a divisional officer is leading a force a subordinate will take command of his division without impact on officer quality rolls. Where several forces are at the same battle the senior force commander will be C-in-C and other force commanders will temporarily return to their divisions.
Stacking & Merging Forces: Where two or more forces of the same army concentrate in one area they can merge or remain separate forces; multiple forces from different armies can concentrate in the same area but they cannot merge (unless they are Anglo-Portuguese, see Anglo-Portuguese command structure below). All count towards the area stacking limit for attrition purposes. Note: Although most forces from different armies cannot merge, they can operate together under a “Joint Command” campaign card. The maximum force that can shelter inside a fortress 30UI. Although there is no maximum area stacking limit, the absolute maximum effective stacking for battle is 100 UI (roughly equating to 25 infantry units plus supporting cavalry and artillery).
Area Occupation: Enemy forces cannot occupy the same area unless one has been invested in a fortress by a force at least equal in strength – a siege is underway.
Force Strength: The strength of a force / division is only tracked in infantry UI. Cavalry is allocated in proportion to the total infantry UI committed to the battle. The army’s cavalry divisor (4-10) is given in army lists; in order for cavalry to be fielded there must be at least 2 cavalry UI (this is the only time a 2 UI unit is allowed); cavalry type is determined randomly. Guns are assigned to a force in half batteries for every 10 UI of infantry and cavalry fielded; half batteries must form full batteries wherever possible; artillery type (horse / foot) is determined randomly. See: Organising Armies Prior To Battle
Disbanding Divisions: The minimum size of a division is 4 ready UI plus any UI in hospital. If a division’s strength falls below 4 ready UI it must move as fast as possible to the nearest friendly fortress (where it will remain until it has 4 ready UI), or it can be disbanded. The UI of disbanded divisions can be redistributed to other forces in the same or an adjacent areas. Voluntary disbandment is allowed at 6 ready UI or less. At no other time can divisional UI be transferred from one division to another. Following disbandment the divisional pin is placed in a fortress and cannot become active again (it is ignored for all campaign purposes) until it reaches 4 ready UI.
Area Attrition Limit: The maximum number of UI, in combined or separate forces, that can be stacked in an area before testing for attrition is fifty.
Anglo-Portuguese Command Structure: At the start of the campaign, up to two British divisions (historically 4th and 6th) can be given to Beresford; they can be merged back into Wellington’s command at any time (see stacking and merging forces above). The Cadiz Division may merge with a Spanish army or Beresford on Wellington’s activation – it must leave that control at Wellington’s request, or if its movement restrictions prevent it from further cooperation.
The Campaign Activation Deck
This deck drives the campaign. The deck is shuffled and placed face down. Then, one at a time, the cards are turned and the instruction on the card followed until the End of Turn card is revealed. ⁹
On turning the End of Turn card attrition for over stacking is assessed. Then, all of the cards of the campaign activation deck are shuffled prior to the start of the next turn.
The first turn of the campaign is a set up turn. This is played as an ordinary turn except: The End of Turn card is removed; players cannot initiate a battle or take / pass through / besiege a key enemy VP area. The turn is purely used to decide dispositions and run through the activation deck. After the set up turn, add the End of Turn card and shuffle the deck: Turn one of the campaign can begin.
Following an army’s activation (on its specific army activation card), each of the army’s forces can move. Forces must move one at a time. Every activation, each forces starts with four movement d6. The d6 is modified as follows:
1. If the force has a green pin deduct two dice.
2. If force is acting on a Forced March campaign card add up to two dice without penalty, or three or four dice with an attrition check.
3. If the force is moving in open terrain add one to the d6 roll.
4. If the force is moving on a major road add one to the d6 roll.
5. If the force is moving in extreme weather deduct one from the d6 roll.
The dice are rolled one at a time: On each roll of 4+ the force may move one area.
Where an active army ends its movement activation in areas adjacent to the enemy it can attempt to initiate one battle. This is not a movement roll.
Attrition Tests: Forces must make an attrition test in the following circumstances by rolling d6:
1. Immediately after adding a third or fourth dice using a Forced March campaign card.
2. If, at the end of a campaign turn the general stacking limit (50 UI) of an area has been exceeded, or they are unable to trace an open supply route (of eight areas or less, point to point) back to a friendly / allied supply fortress; regional capital city; forward supply dump; naval supply port.
If a test is required, each division in an effected force must test by rolling D6. Each division failing to roll 4+ must check for attrition effect.
Attrition Effect: Divide the division’s total UI by six (rounding down all fractions) to discover the number of UI that will go into hospitals.⁵ Hospitalised UI are not marked off of divisional strength because they still count towards force stacking limits. The number of hospitalised UI is noted in the tracker with the turn they were admitted +2 (E.g. UI hospitalised on turn 2 will note a 4 into the hospitals tracker and will be unfit for service until the start of turn 4).
Campaign Cards: Certain campaign cards can be used to negate the effects of attrition:
1. A Logistics campaign card can be played to negate any attrition tests for one force, of any size, in any circumstances.
2. A Naval Supply card can be played to during a player’s activation to create a forward naval supply base: It is treated as a supply fortress, it cannot be used in the activation it is created and it can only supply the forces of one army for one activation unless maintained. Naval supply ports can be overrun and destroyed.
3. A Forward Supply Depot campaign card can be played during a player’s activation to create a forward supply base. It is treated as a supply fortress; it cannot be used in the activation it is created and it can only supply the forces of one army for one activation unless maintained. Forward supply bases can be overrun and destroyed.
Initiating Battle: Having moved all of its forces that wish to move in the current activation, an army may nominate the forces in one area to lead an attack against enemy forces in an adjacent connected area, and indicate all forces that will concentrate in support (see concentration below).
A d6 is rolled, adding one to the roll if the defender is in open terrain, adding one if Wellington, and deducting one from the roll if the force is led by an acting corps commander. If the result is 4+ the defending player must choose to withdraw or stand. Only one attempt to initiate battle is allowed per activation.²
Exception - Major Rivers: After an attack has been initiated, if there is a major river between the attacking and defending areas, the defender may claim the river as defensive terrain by rolling 4+; he does this before choosing to withdraw or stand. In normal weather conditions major rivers will be extremely difficult terrain (require difficulty checks to cross) and have two to four bridges (d3+1) crossing points. If a major river will feature as table-top terrain, the attacker can negate the river by immediately playing a Bridging campaign card; otherwise he has the option to press the attack regardless, or call it off.
Defender Withdraws: If the defender withdraws he does so automatically. The withdrawing force can withdraw one or two areas. Forces defending an area with a fortress can choose to move forces into it (maximum of 30 UI, including hospitalised). The attacker now moves into the vacated area with the leading forces and may also move any concentrating forces into their nominated concentration areas. If the defender has retreated into a fortress, a siege may begin (see sieges below).
Defender Stands: If the defender stands he indicates any forces that will concentrate in support (see concentration below). A battle will now ensue between the attacker and defender, and all concentrating forces.
Pin Movement: Although the battle is said to be fought in the defending area (for terrain determination), and the area will give name to the battle, the battle will probably be fought somewhere in between. Map pins do not relocate during the initiation or concentration process. Pin movement takes place post battle.
Green pins: All forces involved in a battle are marked with a green pin. Numbered green pins are used to indicate any force concentrating with delay. A green pin reduces the movement dice of a force on its subsequent activation card. Green pins do not effect movement during the post battle movement phase; rather, the green pins reflect the loss of subsequent activation movement due to it.
Concentration of Supporting Forces ²: To concentrate for a battle a force must be in an area adjacent and connected to either the attacking area or the defending area.³
Concentrating forces roll a d6 to determine their times of arrival. One is deducted from the roll if the attacker is concentrating in the defending area; one is deducted from the roll if the defender is concentrating in the attacking area; two is deducted from the roll if the concentrating force is pinned by an enemy force that is not itself concentrating and is at least half the strength of the force it is pinning; one is deducted from the roll if the force has a green pin; one is deducted from the roll if the force would normally activate on a different card to the attacking or defending force (unless acting on a Joint Command card).⁴
Concentrating forces will be part of their army’s initial deployment if they roll 4+. Those rolling less arrive after commencement of battle and are activated as delayed off table reserves when their side’s Stratagem sequence card appears.
· A force rolling 1 becomes available as immediate off-table reserve on the fourth appearance of the army’s Stratagem sequence card.
· A force rolling 2 becomes available as immediate off-table reserve on the third appearance of the army’s Stratagem sequence card.
· A force rolling 3 becomes available as immediate off-table reserve on the second appearance of the army’s Stratagem sequence card.
· A force rolling 0 will fail to arrive in time to take any active part in the battle; they still act as per other concentrating forces post battle.
· Cavalry is always available for initial deployment.
Armies & Deployment
Organising Armies Prior To Battle:
1. The player must organise the infantry UI of each division into units (of 3-5 UI in each), then determine type and quality.
2. To work out cavalry UI take the total number of infantry UI that will arrive in time for the upcoming battle and divide them by their relevant cavalry divisor, rounding all fractions up. After working out the total number of cavalry UI the player must organise them into units of 3-5 UI each before randomly determining their type and quality. Exception: Where only 2 cavalry UI are available, a single 2 UI unit is allowed.
3. ¹⁰ To work out the number of artillery half batteries in the force take the total number of infantry and cavalry UI that can arrive in the upcoming battle and divide the total by 10, rounding all fractions up. After working out the number of half batteries the player must form them into full batteries and assign them to infantry divisions (1 per division maximum). Where a half battery is left over it can be assigned to an infantry or cavalry division (if assigned to cavalry it is automatically horse artillery). The number of batteries assigned to immediately available and delayed divisions must be proportional.
Deployment: Both sides roll deployment D6 modified as follows:
· After dicing for C-in-C quality, add one if better battlefield commander, or Wellington.
· Deduct one if acting corps commander.
· Add one if defending.
· Add two if playing a “Kept it in my pocket” battle card.
Table side is chosen by the defender unless his roll was doubled by the attacker. The attacker deploys second unless his roll was doubled by the defender. If both sides rolled the same, roll D6 with highest choosing table side, then each side deploys one division at a time, lowest roll first.
Major Rivers: A major river is placed on the table by the defender after table side is chosen. Bridges are placed by the players alternately, defender placing the first (bridges must be at least 18” apart and 24” in from the table edge).
Immediate Off-Table Reserves: Divisions may be kept in immediate off-table reserve behind the player’s baseline. They may be activated for arrival on an Army Action card (orders are sent), at which point their point of entry (left, right, or centre) must be declared; then they must arrive on the next appropriate march card.
Battle Duration ¹¹: Battles will last a minimum of five full turns. Turns ending prematurely on ‘same domino’ results are not counted towards the total – they are extra time.
Post Battle Casualties
Divisional UI Loss, Hospitalised:
Each divisional infantry unit (constituting UI drawn from the divisional UI pool) will incur one UI loss, hospitalised, if it took any casualties during the battle.⁵ The battle’s loser will always convert half of its hospitalised UI (rounding down all fractions) into permanent losses. Hospitalised UI are not marked off of the divisional UI strength because they still count towards force stacking limits. The number of hospitalised UI is noted in the tracker with the turn they were admitted +2 (E.g. UI hospitalised on turn 2 will note a 4 into the hospitals tracker and will be unfit for service until the start of turn 4).
Divisional UI Loss, Permanent:
An infantry division incurs one permanent UI loss for each of its infantry units at zero UI, routed or destroyed.
The force incurs one permanent UI loss for each of its cavalry or artillery units ending the battle at zero UI, routed or destroyed. The player chooses distribution.
The losing army will incur two permanent UI loss for each enemy light cavalry unit presently at 2 UI strength or more (the losing player chooses distribution).
Post Battle Movement
Primary defending forces roll six d6: For every roll of 4+ the force must retreat one area.
Other defending forces roll five d6: For every roll of 4+ the force retreats one area.
Attacking forces roll four d6: For every roll of 4+ the force retreats one area.
Losing forces may enter a fortress using up any remaining retreat moves. Maximum fortress capacity is 30 UI (including hospitalised UI).
Surrender: If a force is unable to retreat because its escape routes are blocked by enemy pins containing an equal number of UI or more, the force will surrender. Otherwise, the losing force will surrender 20% (rounding up all fractions) of its remaining UI as it breaks out, adding one area of movement to do so if required: The losing player chooses distribution.
Attacking forces move into the defending area, then roll three D6 for each force. For each 4+ a force may move one area to exploit the victory.
Defending forces move into the defending area, then roll two D6 for each force. For each 4+ a force may move one area to exploit the victory.
Draw: Forces remain static with the option to roll any number of retreat dice up to a maximum of five.
When an enemy army enters an enemy fortress area it must invest it with a force of at least 10 UI and equal to the UI within. If it cannot invest the fortress it cannot enter the area or remain in it. Whilst invested the investing player exerts control over the area surrounding the fortress but the besieged player holds the areas victory points until the fortress falls.
Sallying forces can only lead an attack if the fortress area, attacking area and defending area are the same. Relieving forces, leading the attack or concentrating, always count the fortress area as the defending area.
Once invested, a siege can resolved with a Siege Artillery campaign card played on an appropriate army activation. No dice roll is required for initiation by the leading force; external defending forces cannot concentrate this card is in effect.
On an appropriate army activation card, negotiation for surrender may be undertaken – leeway should be given to allow a withdrawal move.
Victory Points ⁸
Each player starts with 22 victory points.
British and Spanish players will each deduct 1 VP for every red or yellow occupation pin lost.
British and Spanish players will each add 1 VP for every red or yellow occupation pin gained.
French players will each deduct 1 VP for every blue occupation pin lost.
French players will each add 1 VP for every blue occupation pin gained.
1 bonus VP will be added for personally gaining an area.
All occupation pin VPs are doubled for losing or gaining fortresses.
Battlefield victory: 2 VP each for the players of the winning side. 1 bonus VP for personally gaining a victory over each 20 UI (rounding fractions) of enemy strength.
For every bonus VP won by the Spanish player roll D6: On 4+ add 1 VP.⁶
· 2nd Army, O’Donnell: Barcelona. 59 UI in 5 divisions.
· 3rd Army, Freire: Valencia. 39 UI in 3 divisions.
· 5th Army, Blake: Sevilla. 40 UI in 3 divisions.
· 6th Army, Santocildes: Santiago. 39 UI in 3 divisions.
· TOTAL: 177 UI in 14 divisions in 4 armies.
· Anglo-Portuguese Army, Wellington: Lisbon. 104 UI in 8 divisions.
· Army of Portugal, Beresford: Elvas. 32 UI in 2 divisions.
· Cadiz Garrison, Graham: Cadiz. 12 UI in 1 division.
· TOTAL: 148 UI in 11 divisions in two armies.
French (player 1):
· Army of the South, Soult: Merida. 112 UI in 7 divisions.
· Army of Catalonia, MacDonald: Toulouse. 51 UI in 4 divisions.
· TOTAL: 163 UI in 11 divisions in two armies.
French (player 2):
· Army of Aragon, Suchet: Zarogoza. 86 UI in 5 divisions.
· Army of Portugal, Marmont: Valladolid. 81 UI in 6 divisions.
· TOTAL: 167 UI in 11 divisions in two armies.
French (alternate activation):
· Army of the Centre, Joseph: Madrid. 36 UI in 3 divisions.
· TOTAL: 36 UI in 3 divisions in one army.
· Allies: 325 UI in 25 divisions in six armies.
· French: 366 UI in 25 divisions in five armies.
Key areas ⁷
These are the areas that are worth VPs. Mark them on the map in red; pin them accordingly.
Galiza: Santiago, Corunna, Vogo Galiza, Cuidad Rodrigo (actually held by the French).
Portugal: Lisbon, Oporto, Coimbra, Almeida, Evora, Estramoz (Elvas).
Gibraltar (Note: This area is deemed impregnable and cannot be besieged).
Palma Majorca (Only included because it is a fortress on the map).
Andalucia: Sevilla, Cadiz (garrisoned by the British), Cordoba, Granada, Berlanga.
Valencia: Valencia, Cartagena, Murcia.
Catalonia: Barcelona, Tortosa, Terragona.
France: Bayonne, Toulouse, Perpignan. (Important Note: Bayonne and Toulouse are impregnable).
Old Castille: Valladolid, Burgos, Santandar, Oviedo, Salamanca.
New Castille: Madrid, Toledo, Albacete, Cuidad Real, Turuel.
Extremadura: Merida, Badajoz, Caceres, Navalmoral.
Aragon: Zaragoza, San Sebastian, Pamplona, Huesca.
I will send these rules out in MS Word (not in a locked PDF) to anyone who wants them, along with the full OOB / Army Lists and so forth, so you can play around with your own edits where necessary. However, in return, I ask that you respect my copyright and refrain from publishing them electronically or in hard copy except for your own personal use - thanks.
I have referenced some of these notes in the rules but, not all of them, or in any particular order. They were done very much as an afterthought, and quickly, to explain why I did things the way I did, or to offer editing suggestions.
Now, this is not a very detailed wargame campaign. It is just a few pages of basic rule outlines. I have always found that complicated campaigns falter because they require too much work by the players and the umpire / adjudicator (the latter usually being me). I have tried to boil things down to the minimum required. This is a wargame campaign that intends to do nothing more than pose some basic strategic / grand tactical questions and generate wargame battles with wargame consequences for future battles. I hope you weren’t hoping for tables on how certain personalities react in different circumstances, how to run a wargame economy, or how to build spy networks, etc.
I came to a lot of the rules for this campaign because of the campaign map, which was made by someone else (an excellent resource; thank you, ‘Murat’), and looking at the maps in Osprey’s Peninsular War Atlas at how armies were quite dispersed for much of the time. I liked the fact that armies weren’t all in one place but were in mutually supporting locals. Obviously, this is hard to reproduce on a node to node map with 30 – 40 miles between nodes but, I wanted army dispersals to have that feel. In consequence there is quite a lot of abstraction going on: I play with the map distances and pin location to a very large degree. It’s definitely a system that comes out of left field; it’s quite possible that I’m insane. My advice is not to think about it too much and give the ideas a whirl. Hopefully, the rules will give the feel of strategic movement by Napoleonic armies – dispersing into columns before concentrating to fight. If the rules do that, they have succeeded. More on this below.
Because this campaign was going to be played without an umpire secret 'unscripted' ploys and the like would be hard to do. In consequence, I introduced a 61 card Campaign Events deck into the mix. Doing so opened so many doors that this card deck expanded at a rapid rate of knots – eventually encompassing everything from units in ambush to siege resolution. They are the one thing that I can’t fully check without hours and hours of playtesting. I’ll report on my blog if I change or add any. There is always scope for you to make more cards of your own (or change / discard the one’s you don’t like).
If you were wondering what the start date for this campaign is, it is 1811ish with simplified areas of occupation to get the thing going. As wargame campaigns generally changes the historical narrative the moment they start, I found no compelling reason not to use a lot of fudge here.
Starting army organisations and numbers were taken from Oman. One glaring omission from the French army list is the Army of the North – about 75,000 men have disappeared. Well not exactly disappeared. As most of you will know, historically the AoN was dispersed into garrisons all over northern and central Spain and couldn’t concentrate because if it had the whole of that part of Spain would have risen up in open revolt – probably ending the war in Spain’s favour within months. Imagine that the 75,000 men of the AoN are there but, they are running round northern and central Spain like blue arsed flies keeping the hostile population subdued, keeping supply routes open and chasing two ever elusive Spanish armies about the place (these numbered about 25,000 men and would pop without warning, cause havoc in the French rear areas, then disappear like smoke - they are also absent): It’s all going on – we just don’t need to concern ourselves with it. My wargame campaign rational for these three armies going completely AWOL were twofold. Firstly, if you give the French players another army of 75,000 men they will use it as a field army (which historically it wasn’t) and it will unbalance the campaign too much. Secondly, I didn’t want to have to work out a lot of unwieldy rules for revolts, garrisons and policing (which probably wouldn’t work anyway) and I certainly didn’t want to spend a lot of time adjudicating this aspect of a wargame campaign in Spain. Suffice to say that the French did manage to keep the lid on Spanish dissatisfaction in occupied areas (to a modest degree, at least) but it took a lot of manpower to do it.
Notes on unit scale: I am using a home grown version of classic Piquet to fight my battles. In this version of the rules a unit is 3 – 5 Unit Integrity points strong, most typically having 4 UI. With this campaign strength in mind it shouldn’t be too difficult to convert this system to other available table-top sets, many having a roughly similar ‘stand based’ system: Black Powder small, medium, and large units; Soldiers of Napoleon has a roughly comparable basic mechanism too. Where your rules count heads, I suggest that you simply divide heads by UI, counting average sized units as 4 UI – though you might need to tinker with what losses trigger post battle hospitalisation depending on your game casualty rates.
When it comes to the overall scale of this campaign, I had to play about with my usual scaling of things too. Normally, for one off fictional battles, I typically have divisions of five or six 4 UI units (when a UI is 250-ish infantry, 150-ish cavalry). The scale of this campaign, where there will be a lot of divisions being brought to battle, made that impossible for me to do with the number of units and table size that I have; this is also the chief reason for the arbitrary 100 UI maximum allowed for an army in battle. In this campaign an infantry UI is about 400 men. My collection is not huge but, at 2700 or so figures, I realise it might be more than most can muster outside of a club / group setting – I can’t help that I’m afraid; these rules were not written as a commercial exercise, they were tailored to my own collection. I’m sure, that if you don’t have the numbers, you too can tinker your way around the scaling.
You will note that I didn’t add cavalry divisions as such to the army lists. This is because they most frequently operated as brigades and I didn’t want to track the location of formations that small. I think I pinched the divisor idea from Age of Reason rules where they use it for artillery – it’s a simple mechanism which puts a proportion of cavalry with each ‘pin on the map’. The army cavalry divisor numbers came about by looking at historical proportions where I could find them. See note on artillery below.
Card Decks: These are best printed onto thin card and put into standard size collector card plastic sleeves. Card sleeves make homemade cards 100% uniform and a joy to shuffle; they are well worth the investment. You’ll need just shy of 100 sleeves – buy them all the same colour to lessen the number of packs (usually 50 per pack) you will need to buy.
¹ Four player campaign: This campaign was designed for four players: One British; one Spanish; two French (Suchet & Marmont; Soult & MacDonald; Joseph as a joint command). A few more or less players could be employed with little difficulty: It could be played with a minimum of two; five is probably best done by splitting the Spanish; six by re-dividing the French as equally as possible (with Joseph’s army added to the player army mix and possibly allowing him to operate outside of New Castille) into a three player faction. More than that and you start getting into the realms of one army players, which is doable but players might get bored awaiting their activation. I suggest the British should not be divided unless absolutely necessary because its strategic strength was its ‘one general’ (Wellington) command structure.
² Initiating battle on 4+: This dice roll is a simple way of abstracting the act of bringing an enemy to battle or forcing him to withdraw. Where the dice roll is unsuccessful, assume that the defender is manoeuvring to avoid action whilst remaining in the same general area, or the circumstances are such that the attacking commander feels it best to decline the opportunity to attack.
There is an argument to say that if both sides want a battle you should let them have one but, I went against that idea. I believe that the player is only that; he may want a general to act in a certain way but the general, being in independent command, and without an 'eye in the sky', might have other ideas. Picture Napoleon in Paris, fuming at what he thought ‘lack of will’ by his generals in Spain – well, he’s you.
³ Concentration distance: In reality, forces on adjacent area nodes would be too far apart to concentrate quickly if true distance was being measured. However, we must imagine that a map node serves more as a ‘way point’ for campaign movement than a precise geographical force location: Imagine that a force can be anywhere between the node it is in and the nodes it is connected to.
⁴ Concentrating in the other side’s area: This is game mechanic abstraction of command and control difficulty and has little to do with geographical pin position or direction of attack. When the attacker concentrates in the attacking area or the defender concentrates in the defending area command and control is deemed to be at its optimum. Other concentrations are deemed to be more difficult – the force is coming to the field by a circuitous route, or the transfer of orders is not so smooth – and there is more chance of things going awry. Remember what I said about force location and area nodes on the map, well this is all part of the same insane idea.
⁵ Hospitalisation: ‘Hospitalised UI’ represent the temporary loss of divisional effectiveness and morale in as simple a way as I could think of: Very little extra paperwork is required, no extra modifiers are required for troop quality rolls following adverse combat results, etc.
⁶ Spanish bonus VP handicap: This is a ‘handicapped bonus’ for the Spanish player – he’ll probably need it. Another handicap bonus is the rate at which Spanish armies can recruit on the Spanish Drafts activation card.
⁷ Key areas: Most key areas (for VP capture / loss value) were obvious. Others were chosen as a best fit or simply at random; in war, some places become more important than history would previously hint at so I felt quite comfortable doing this.
Estramoz in Portugal (facing Badajoz) needs to be made into a fortress on the map – it also represents the frontier fortress at nearby Elvas.
Toulouse and Bayonne both count as ‘regional capitals’ for supply purposes and need to be underlined on the map. In reality, until 1813/14 any invasion of France by the Allies would have provoked a huge response from Napoleon. In consequence I have decided to make Toulouse and Bayonne impregnable to the Allies. They can be moved through but they can’t be taken (they counter-balance Palma and Gibraltar). This campaign is not about invading France!
⁸ Victory Conditions: What constitutes an overall strategic victory in this campaign is a moot point: I think players will know it when they see it. However, only one player can actually win the game by having the most VPs at the end of it – although highly unlikely, he could even be on the side that strategically loses. This game is about personal glory and advancement rather than ‘jingoistic patriotism’: The best (luckiest) general wins - after that, position only grades different types of loser. I thought this the best way of introducing the historical element of non-cooperation between the Allies and the rank narcissism of certain French Marshals.
⁹ Elastic time: Controversially, campaign turns do not have a time scale. For the purposes of this campaign time is elastic: A turn can be one day or several months. This allows for a better campaign narrative: Battles occurring on consecutive activations might actually be separated by weeks, or they might be the second day of the same action – it will be up to the campaign diarist to decide how events are written up. Only the sequence of activations is important, the time each activation takes and the time between activations is not. The campaign will take as long as it takes and, without a clock running, historical events elsewhere in the world cannot effect it – E.g. Napoleon doesn’t need to abdicate on campaign turn twelve and bring an enjoyable Peninsular wargame campaign, at the crux of a decision, to an early end!
¹⁰ Artillery balance: Because infantry divisions in this game are usually only three or four units strong I found it difficult, under my home grown version of Piquet table-top, to get the power ratio of artillery to everything else right. With one full battery per division (as it historically should be) artillery would be far too dominant. If your rules allow for reasonably effective half batteries go for one per division, otherwise you'll need to do it like me and combine them and not have one per division - it was a fudge.¹¹ Battle Duration: In my table-top battles there are a minimum of five full turns during which units will, in the best circumstances, get fifteen chances to move: Infantry in line and open terrain could move up to 11’ 3” on those cards. In my opinion a relatively ‘short’ battle encourages players, especially those attacking, to be decisive; overly ‘long’ battles allow too much to happen in a single day, allow long (lazy) periods of inaction and don’t allow an outnumbered defender to play for nightfall (a draw) – the latter being an important consideration in a campaign setting.