Thursday, 13 December 2012

Cerignola - One last time

Last night I christened the upgraded war game table with another refight of Cerignola. The deployment featured the alternate (and not very historical) set up of having the French artillery present; plus a few other minor balancing changes.

Probably the biggest change occurred off table, so to speak. I have been working on the rules and I have classified the troop types differently. The Spanish infantry were downgraded to 'C Class' (D8 CC, D6 DD) with arquebus specialist status. This massively changed how the battle was fought - there were no grizzled Spanish veterans here! The Swiss were 'A Class' (D12 CC, D8 DD) with stubborn status. The reversion to rather old school classifications (A - E) has proved to be a very useful and flexible tool for this period.
The other alteration is to bite the bullet and do away with, light through heavy, artillery classification. After much reading, I have decided that the weight of artillery is of little matter in a field battle situation. Artillery in the early 16th century was so inaccurate, and so slow firing, and the quality of powder and projectile construction was so varied, that the size of a cannon ball would make little difference (except when fired at castle walls and the like). This flies in the face of most wargames rules, but just because cannon size features in most renaissance rule sets doesn't mean it is based in fact - personally, I now rather think it is based in 'wargames tradition'. Crew quality, and the quality of the cannon's construction, was probably far more important at this date so it is probably better to adjust fire dice by crew classification - usually D class (D6, D6), C class (D8, D6) for the good stuff (French?), with specialist shooter status for the very best.

So what happened? Well. here is a short report.

 The French launched the Swiss at the defences
 Routing a Spanish colunela.
As the melee continued between the Swiss and German pike, the French launched their Gendarmes into the fray.
On the other side of the field French pike were halted at the ditch and subjected to volley after volley of deadly arquebus and cannon fire.
The fight became general along the entire front of the defences.
Following an explosion (Stratagem) in the lines, the french gain an advantage and cross the earthwork.
Fabricio is killed. The Landsknechts, after a fight that lasted most of the battle, finally give way.
The Spanish position is outflanked.
The French have won!!!!

Peter has won; again; bastard. I tried three bloody times to win this battle using the French, and he does it first time!










Next week we will fight an open field battle. It will be fictional, but might involve the same armies.

Chow.

9 comments:

Gunny Highway said...

James,
I think youve hit on what we can do with this hobby... Change certain parameters for a battle and see if it could have "turned the tide" so to speak. Glad to see the table is finished and you and Peter are playing again....
Respectfully,
Gunny

Phil said...

Wonderful figures and beautiful table, really impressive!
Phil.

Steve's Wargame Stuff said...

Stunning looking set up!

Steve's Wargame Stuff said...

Stunning looking set up!

Geordie an Exiled FoG said...

Fantastic looking game :)

Gonsalvo said...

Looks great as always. A good illustration of how a few changes can really alter a scenario. In my version, The Spanish pikes are allowed Battlemass only - no match for the Landsknechts or Swiss if they come through without heavy casualties. The one time the French won, even with that, I forgot to bring the 2nd unit of Genitors, and that allowed the same kind of outflanking that ultimately won the day after a very hard fought battle.

JLPmaquetas said...

Fantastica batalle y preciosas las figuras. ¡¡ Impresionante !!

Jose Luis

JLPmaquetas said...

Blisimo campo de batalla y preciosas figuras.

Jose Luis

JLPmaquetas said...

Bellisimo campo de batalla y preciosas figuras.

JoseLuis